Measuring the impact of code dependencies on software. Traditional clustering techniques based on the principle of low coupling and high cohesion, various clustering algorithms have been proposed 3,1618,23,26. Database recovery techniques in dbms geeksforgeeks. Hence the text details not only modeling techniques. Applicants who are interested in a masters degree program related to software architecture must have a bachelors degree in a stemrelated field with a minimum gpa of 2. Pdf comparing software architecture recovery techniques. Software architecture recovery based on pattern matching. Our methods have been implemented in a tool, called.
Software architecture recovery is the process of inspecting software systems and. Architecture recovery deals with the issues of recovering the past design decisions that has been. Software architecture is foundational to the development of large, practical softwareintensive applications. Small release time and quick delivery has become the main objective of the software industry, these days. Proceedings of the third international workshop on software architecture software architecture recovery and restructuring through clustering techniques. Software architecture recovery and restructuring through clustering techniques. From its very inception, the study of software architecture has recognized architectural decay as a regularly occurring phenomenon in longlived systems. First, we study the impact of leveraging accurate symbol dependencies on the accuracy. Despite this improvement, the overall accuracy is low for all recovery techniques. Introduction to architecture recovery he software architecture of a program or computing system is the structure or structures of the system, which comprise software elements, the externally visible properties.
Software architecture is foundational to the development of large, practical software intensive applications. Formal languages for representing and reasoning about software architecture. Despite decays prevalence, there is a relative dearth of empirical data regarding the nature of architectural changes that may lead to. Keywords software architecture recovery groundt ruth software. Architecture techniques are elements or principles that can be used to design buildings and other structures. Architecture techniques it is an iterative and incremental approach consisting of five main steps that helps to generate candidate solutions.
This paper presents an quantitative approach based on clustering techniques for software architecture restructuring and reengineering as well as for software architecture recovery. What is needed more is a systematic and effective approach to help the designer to restructure or reengineer an architecture for improvement. Reconstructing and evolving software architectures using a. General methods for software architecture recovery. Architecture recovery based on design rule hierarchy. Leveraging design rules to improve software architecture. This study improves on previous studies in two ways. It discusses their activation models and quality attributes. Styles provide a way to effectively reuse hardwon domain and engineering knowledge. In the 37th international conference on software engineering icse, software engineering in practice track, 2015. I was surprised by the omission of working with legacy systems, productlinefamily architectures and modeldriven architecture mda. The most recent study 10 collected the groundtruth architectures of eight systems and used them this is the authors version of an article that has been published in this journal.
We observe that important features of modern software architecture are not exploited to improve architecture recovery techniques. A largescale study of architectural evolution in opensource. Many automated techniques of varying accuracy have been developed to help recover the architecture of a software system from its implementation. However, existing approaches often are limited only to software architecture recovery in the. Access study documents, get answers to your study questions, and connect with real tutors for cis 433.
Software architecture recovery and restructuring through. In this paper, we use these architectures as ground truths in performing a comparative analysis of six stateoftheart software architecture recovery techniques. This brandnew text covers all facets of software architecture and how it serves as the intellectual centerpiece of software development and evolution. Evolution in software architecture recovery techniques a survey abstract. Software architecture recovery is a set of methods for the extraction of architectural information from lower level representations of a software system, such as. The result should use common modeling standards sysml, uml, etc. A comparative analysis of software architecture recovery. We define architecture recovery as a process of identifying and extracting higher level of abstractions from existing software systems 2. Software architecture is an important part of the software systems showing its components and connection between the components. The largest software system used in the published evaluations of architecture recovery techniques comprises 4msloc, and it revealed the scalability limit of several recovery techniques 10. Abstractmany techniques have been proposed to automatically recover software architectures from software implementations. For legacy and simplicity reasons, we will also use this terminology in the remainder. Many techniques have been proposed to automati cally recover software architectures from software implementa tions. Previous comparative studies while informative and providing preliminary hints as to the respective quality of different recovery techniqueshave been limited in a number of ways.
The result or output of the architecture design process is an architectural description. The basic architecture design process is composed of the following steps. Oct 23, 2008 the future of sar integrating with forward engineering continuous supervision, architectural. Finally, chapter 4 delves into the challenge of software architecture recovery, or the techniques and processes required to uncover an existing systems architecture based on available information, including reverseengineering and exploration of a systems major properties. Proceedings of the third international workshop on software architecture software architecture recovery and restructuring through clustering techniques pages 101104. Architectural styles architectural styles are reusable packages of design decisions and constraints that are applied to an architecture to induce chosen desirable qualities. Chapter 10 builds upon the previous chapter by increasing the scalescope of view of design principles to the application of architectural patterns and architectural styles. A largescale study of architectural evolution in open. So to prevent data loss recovery techniques based on deferred update and immediate update or backing up data can be used.
Ieee 1471 is the short name for a standard formally known as ansiieee 14712000, recommended practice for architecture description of software intensive systems. Software architecture techniques at strayer university, virginia beach. Dec 28, 2017 evolution in software architecture recovery techniques a survey abstract. To that end, a number of software architecture recovery techniques have been designed koschke 2009. Software architecture recovery is a set of methods for the extraction of architectural information from lower level representations of a software system, such as source code. Software architecture recovery aims to reverse engineer a software architecture description from the system artifacts e. Each view addresses a set of system concerns, following the conventions of its viewpoint, where a viewpoint is a specification that describes the notations, modeling, and analysis techniques to use in a view that expresses. The results suggest that 1 in addition to architecture recovery techniques, the accuracy of dependencies used as their inputs is another factor to consider for high recovery accuracy, and 2 more accurate recovery techniques are needed. The sacam compares the architectures of software systems and not the implementation code. Many techniques have been proposed to automatically recover software architectures from software implementations. The hardware architecture the software architect in turn provides requirements to the system architect, who configures the hardware architecture. For legacy and simplicity reasons, we will also use this terminology in. Measuring the impact of code dependencies on software architecture recovery techniques by thibaud lutellier a thesis presented to the university of waterloo in ful llment of the thesis requirement for the degree of master of applied science in electrical and computer engineering waterloo, ontario, canada, 2015 c thibaud lutellier 2015.
Architecture recovery and reengineering to handle legacy code is critical for large and complex systems. Software architecture recovery using data mining techniques. Evolution in software architecture recovery techniques a. Pdf general methods for software architecture recovery. However, rigorously assessing these techniques has been hampered by the lack of architectural ground truths. First, we study the impact of leveraging accurate symbol dependencies on the accuracy of architecture recovery. Comparing software architecture recovery techniques using.
The techniques used to recover the lost data due to system crash, transaction errors, viruses, catastrophic failure, incorrect commands execution etc. The software architecture comparison analysis method. Architectural decay is caused by repeated, sometimes careless changes to a system during its lifespan. Each view addresses a set of system concerns, following the conventions of its viewpoint, where a viewpoint is a specification that describes the notations, modeling, and analysis techniques to use in a view that expresses the architecture. Despite decays prevalence, there is a relative dearth of empirical data regarding the nature of. These techniques are often evaluated and compared using largescale legacy systems, such as linux and mozilla 6. Ieee 1471 enhances the content of an architectural description, in particular, giving specific meaning to context, views, and viewpoints. They are independent of style and represent a toolkit for architects to develop unique designs. Formal languages for representing and reasoning about software. System architecture recovery and analysis sara sbir. Software architecture recovery selected material courtesy oscar nierstrasz friday, november 4, 11. A comparative analysis of software architecture recovery techniques.
Professor of computer science at carnegie mellon university since 1990 before then in industry test and measurement research interests software architecture tools and techniques selfhealing and selfadaptive systems connection with nasa engagement since 2004 sabbatical at jpl summer of 2006. Capturing of software architecture is critical for maintenance and evolution. The abstraction process to generate architectural elements frequently involves clustering source code entities such as files, classes, functions etc. Lego, which uses dynamic analysis to recover a class hierarchy. Leveraging design rules to improve software architecture recovery. Critically, this text focuses on supporting creation of real implemented systems. Software architecture recovery using data mining techniques kamran sartipi kostas kontogiannis university of waterloo n data mining allows to reveal cohesive groups of entities in the form of bipartite subgraphs in the graph of the target system. The sacam uses several architecture techniques developed by the software engineering institute seism to compare the architecture candidates. However, existing approaches often are limited only to software architecture recovery in the reverse engineering process. Other areas for software architecture research include architectural analysis techniques, architecture recovery and reengineering, tools and environments for architectural design, architecture refinement from specification to implementation, and case studies of deployed software architectures. Therefore in even relatively new systems similar to long lived systems, developers are faced with a body of code that they need to understand, and from which they need to extract architectural knowledge. Many software architecture recovery techniques have been produced for many than three decades to help deal with the problem of architectural drift and erosion. All in all, the art of software architecture looks to be a very informative book that covers the basics of software architecture, design, and quality that i wish all software developers knew.
Proceedings of the 3rd international workshop on software architecture. Automated recovery of software system designs software. In the proposed model, a highlevel view of a software system in terms of abstract components and their constrained interactions is represented as a query using a. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. Every system is a legacy system, the moment a programmer writes a line of code it becomes a legacy. Ducasse and pollet 19 provide a practitioneroriented survey of over thirty existing approaches for software architecture recovery. Most software systems developed using objectoriented programming languages e. Comparing software architecture recovery techniques using accurate dependencies.
Software architecture descriptions are commonly organized into views, which are analogous to the different types of blueprints made in building architecture. Abstractmany automated techniques of varying accuracy have been developed to help recover the architecture of a software system from its implementation. This book presents a model and an environment for recovering high level design of legacy software systems based on user defined architectural patterns and graph matching techniques. The size of software is increasing, and many software projects are signi. A thorough comparison among the recovery techniques is needed to understand their effectiveness and applicability. Mar 29, 2015 every system is a legacy system, the moment a programmer writes a line of code it becomes a legacy. Many architecture recovery techniques have been proposed 27, 21. Keywordsreverse engineering, architecture recovery, architecture artifacts, reengineering. Previous comparative studies while informative and providing preliminary hints as to the respective quality of different recovery techniques have been limited in a number of ways. We use a number of metrics to assess each technique for its ability to identify a systems architectural components and overall architectural structure. Collaborative architecture recovery product family architecture ecosystem architecture software architecture recovery mircea lungu, 2008.
928 1538 1097 107 65 288 1269 1312 1019 866 744 425 1040 1237 1325 693 1498 903 322 839 589 1209 1044 204 1013 695 229 1081 619 524 541 1426 409 897 928